Why what looked like good news for charter schools actually wasn’t

It seemed like good news for charter schools when a study released this summer declared that they get better student outcomes than do traditional public schools — at least from 2015 to 2019, the years for which researchers said they crunched the numbers. The Wall Street Journal editorial board hailed the results as showing “huge learning gains over union schools” (with “union schools” used as a pejorative reference to public schools in traditional school districts). Education Week’s headline declared: “Charter Schools Now Outperform Traditional Public Schools, Sweeping Study Finds.”

But the study, it turned out, doesn’t show that at all. The headlines were wrong. For one thing, a close look at the results revealed only tiny improvements in charter schools. That, plus concerns critics have raised about the validity of the methodology and definitions used in the study, render moot the claims of besting traditional public schools.

The “not what they seem” theme of the study results reflect the uncertain position in which charter schools find themselves these days. The vanguard of the “school choice” movement when the first charter opened in 1992 in Minneapolis, these schools have been eclipsed in the national debate about “school choice” by programs that use public money for private and religious schools, including vouchers, tax credit programs and education savings accounts.

Please help put parents in charge of their child’s education by forwarding this article to other parents, family, friends and voters.
One open locker in a hallway. by Laura Rivera is licensed under Unsplash unsplash.com

Other Articles

California students among nation’s worst for math and language
State is falling short in some very important indices of societal achievement, such as public education
Read More
When culture wars rip through California school boards, should the state intervene?
Last week’s tussles between state officials and a pair of Southern California school boards may have died down, but they’ve thrown a spotlight on deeper tensions over who makes decisions for local schools — a rift that’s likely to grow as the culture wars escalate.
Read More
Educator Warns that "Teachers Pay Teachers" Can Actually Get You Fired
Teachers Pay Teachers is a great source for educators who want to help fellow teachers while earning extra cash. Sadly, it can also get them fired.
Read More
Inside the fight to keep parents in the know about their kids’ gender in California schools
A Southern California school district requires teachers and staff to notify parents when their children say they have been bullied, are considering self-harm, or decide to publicly identify as a gender opposite their biological sex at school.
Read More
Survey: Teachers Work More Hours Per Week Than Other Working Adults
Higher pay is crucial, but working conditions and well-being must also be addressed to attract and retain educators.
Read More
A journey of student loans: from high schoolers to graduating college
With October marking the start of federal student loan repayments, thousands of borrowers will face the looming reality that has been paused since 2020.
Read More
School year already underway at some California districts as start dates keep creeping earlier
California school districts have moved away from the September return to school that was common in California and other states until the 1990s.
Read More
School spirit days are great for students — even if they stress parents out
Many of us remember the school spirit days of simpler times: Pajama Day, Wacky Wednesday, Superhero Day, or Ugly Sweater Day.
Read More

Get latest news delivered daily!

We will send you breaking news right to your inbox

© 2025 educationopportunity.org, Privacy Policy | FPPC #1460602