Why what looked like good news for charter schools actually wasn’t

It seemed like good news for charter schools when a study released this summer declared that they get better student outcomes than do traditional public schools — at least from 2015 to 2019, the years for which researchers said they crunched the numbers. The Wall Street Journal editorial board hailed the results as showing “huge learning gains over union schools” (with “union schools” used as a pejorative reference to public schools in traditional school districts). Education Week’s headline declared: “Charter Schools Now Outperform Traditional Public Schools, Sweeping Study Finds.”

But the study, it turned out, doesn’t show that at all. The headlines were wrong. For one thing, a close look at the results revealed only tiny improvements in charter schools. That, plus concerns critics have raised about the validity of the methodology and definitions used in the study, render moot the claims of besting traditional public schools.

The “not what they seem” theme of the study results reflect the uncertain position in which charter schools find themselves these days. The vanguard of the “school choice” movement when the first charter opened in 1992 in Minneapolis, these schools have been eclipsed in the national debate about “school choice” by programs that use public money for private and religious schools, including vouchers, tax credit programs and education savings accounts.

Please help put parents in charge of their child’s education by forwarding this article to other parents, family, friends and voters.
One open locker in a hallway. by Laura Rivera is licensed under Unsplash unsplash.com

Other Articles

Weighing in on Reforming the Education System, Just in Time for the New School Year
School is now back in session all across the nation. As kids fill the classrooms and teachers start the curriculum, the cracks in the US education system are becoming clearer than ever. Ignoring the problems will only make things worse
Read More
A journey of student loans: from high schoolers to graduating college
With October marking the start of federal student loan repayments, thousands of borrowers will face the looming reality that has been paused since 2020.
Read More
New California law guarantees 30-minute recess break for school-aged children
School-aged kids across California will have a mandatory 30-minute recess break starting with the 2024-25 school year under a bill Gov. Gavin Newsom recently signed into law.
Read More
Time to retire the tainted, unfair basic skills test for teachers
From its origins in 1982, the California Basic Educational Skills Test, which purports to measure the universal reading, writing and math skills needed to perform in all the varied public school jobs requiring credentials, has been controversial for deterring tens of thousands of educators of color from entering the public school workforce.
Read More
Depending on Where You Teach, It Could Take 5 to 12 Years to Repay Your Debts
For educators, the state they teach in can affect how long it takes them to pay off their loans.
Read More
Examining the impact of California's ban on affirmative action in public schools
California banned affirmative action in public schools in 1996. NPR's A Martinez talks to Zachary Bleemer, incoming assistant professor of economics at Princeton University, about the ban's impact.
Read More
Santa Barbara teachers demand fair pay as negotiations with district loom
More than 150 community members turned out to demand the Santa Barbara Unified School District listen to teachers’ calls for fair pay during a school board meeting on Oct. 4, the Santa Barbara Independent reported.
Read More
Crowded classes, staff shortages, insufficient pay are making some California teachers rethink careers
California schools don’t pay enough to teachers or have the resources to meet the needs of its students, according to a CTA survey of educators.
Read More

Get latest news delivered daily!

We will send you breaking news right to your inbox

© 2025 educationopportunity.org, Privacy Policy | FPPC #1460602